Ask ten business owners why they set up as an LLC and you’ll hear about eight versions of “someone told me to.” That’s not a knock on anyone. But the structure you picked on day one decides how much tax you pay every year after, and it rarely gets a second look.
So which one is best? It depends on your profit, your plans, and how much paperwork you’ll put up with.
The Four Usual Choices
| Structure | How it’s taxed | Self-employment tax | Paperwork | Often a fit for |
| Sole proprietorship | Profit goes on your personal return | On all net profit | Very light | New or part-time businesses |
| LLC (single owner) | Like a sole proprietorship, by default | On all net profit | Light, plus state filings | Owners who want liability protection |
| S corporation | Profit passes through to owners | Only on the salary you pay yourself | Payroll and a separate return | Profitable owner-run businesses |
| C corporation | The company pays tax, then owners pay tax on dividends | Only on salary | The most | Companies raising outside money |
What trips people up most is that an LLC isn’t a tax category. It’s a legal wrapper. A single-owner LLC is taxed exactly like a sole proprietorship unless it files Form 2553 and elects S corporation treatment. Plenty of owners think “I’m an LLC, so I’m covered,” and they’re still paying the same self-employment tax as before.
When a Business Structure and Tax Optimization CPA Consultant Is Worth the Call
Not every business needs to change anything. A side business making $15,000 a year is usually fine as it is. The math starts shifting once profit grows.
Take a Jacksonville consultant netting $120,000 as a sole proprietor. Self-employment tax runs roughly 15.3% on most of that, so somewhere near $17,000. Run the same business as an S corporation with a reasonable salary of $70,000, and payroll taxes apply only to the salary, about $10,700. That’s a gap of around $6,000 a year. Some of it goes to payroll processing and an extra tax return, but what’s left is real money.
“Reasonable” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. The salary has to look like what someone would earn doing your job somewhere else. Pay yourself $20,000 to dodge payroll tax and you’re inviting an IRS letter.
Other moments worth a conversation: adding a partner, taking investor money, or planning a sale.
What a Business Structure and Tax Optimization CPA Consultant Actually Weighs
It’s never just one number. Profit matters, now and next year. State rules matter too. Florida has no personal income tax, which is good news for owners of LLCs and S corporations. C corporations are a different story. They pay Florida’s 5.5% corporate income tax on top of the 21% federal rate.
Then there’s the exit. If you plan to sell in five years, the structure that makes the sale cleanest might not be the one that saves the most today.
Timing counts as well. To be an S corporation for a given year, Form 2553 generally has to be filed within two months and 15 days after that tax year starts. Miss it, and you may be waiting a year or asking the IRS for late-election relief.
At Tilbrook CPA Firm we lay the options side by side in dollars, so the choice isn’t abstract. Our business structure and tax strategy service explains how that review works.
Questions to Bring to a Business Structure and Tax Optimization CPA Consultant
Bring a few blunt ones. What do I actually save after the new costs? What extra filings land on my desk? If things change, how hard is this to undo? Does any of it touch my personal liability? A good consultant answers those plainly. If you’re hearing jargon instead, push back.
Tilbrook CPA Firm works with owners in Jacksonville, Ponte Vedra, Fernandina Beach, and around Florida. A lot of them aren’t starting fresh. They set something up years ago and suspect it no longer fits.
Is an S Corporation Always Better Than an LLC?
No. At modest profit levels, the extra payroll and filing costs can wipe out the savings. We often tell newer owners to give it a year and look again. That advice from Tilbrook CPA Firm surprises people who expected a sales pitch.
Can You Change Your Structure Later?
Yes, though some moves carry tax costs. Switching from a C corporation to an S corporation, for example, comes with its own rules. Talk it through with Tilbrook CPA Firm before you file anything.
Your structure should grow with the business. If nobody has looked at yours since the day you filed with the state, it’s probably time, and Tilbrook CPA Firm is glad to do it.